WEXFORD: 724-934-4700
HARMARVILLE: 412-794-8348

Main Menu

From hand-crafted Chef inspired soups & fresh breads to the best selection of classic Italian meats and aged, old world cheeses,  we’re sure that you will find something to satisfy your palette.

  • Please note:  Some menu items are available in certain locations only.
wmmb_logoWe use only the finest ingredients in all of our recipes and we are proud to feature the world’s best cheese, Wisconsin Cheese.
MAKE IT A BOWL! – Turn your cup of soup into a bowl for a $1 more!
COMBOS – Pick Two! Any 1/2 of a Signature Sandwich, Regular Sandwich or Panini PLUS a side, side salad or cup of soup.


Soup of the Day

Two Chef Selection Soups of the Day!

*Harmarville location features 1 soup of the day selection.

Italian Wedding

Zuppa’s Traditional wedding soup made with housemade meatballs, spinach, and orzo pasta.

Tomato Bisque

Slow roasted tomato soup finished with a touch of cream and sherry.

Spicy Corn and Shrimp Chowder

Chef Mike’s Famous!

Fresh Shrimp made with fire roasted corn and Idaho potatoes finished with cream.

Stuffed Pepper Soup

Hearty tomato soup, rice & ground beef with peppers and a hint of spice

wexford location only


Chicken Salad

Zuppa’s chicken salad with grapes, walnuts and romaine lettuce on toasted wheat bread.

Fish Tacos

4 flour tortillas stuffed with battered white fish, broccoli slaw and a tangy sauce drizzled with chipolte aioli.

wexford location only

Pulled Pork

Baby Swiss and our signature BBQ sauce on a large Kaiser roll. Slow roasted daily!

Tuna Salad

Housemade tuna salad on toasted wheat bread with romaine lettuce.  “Make it a Melt” with American cheese and sliced tomatoes.

Tuna Melt

Housemade tuna salad on wheat bread, panini pressed with sliced tomatoes and white American cheese.


Mac & Cheese

Stick to your ribs good!!!

White Cheddar and Brie

Baked Beans

Cannellini, kidney and pinto beans, bacon baked daily in a sweet and tangy sauce.

wexford location only

Beans & Greens

A blend of Cannellini beans, bacon and spinach in a light chicken broth...

“Mom’s” Deviled Eggs

Jill’s own recipe… If you’re nice enough she might give it to you!!!

Spoon Bread

Sweet corn & white cheddar souffle “Baked to perfection”

wexford location only

Signature Sandwiches

The ‘Italian Club’

Cappicola, turkey, applewood bacon and Genoa salami “club style”, arugula, sliced tomatoes and mayo on toasted Italian bread.

wexford location only

The ‘Little Italy’

Prosciutto di Parma, fresh mozzarella, cracked black pepper, extra virgin olive oil, arugula and a fig spread on toasted Italian bread.

wexford location only

The "Pastrami Melt"

Beef pastrami layered with honey mustard, carmelized onions, bananna peppers & provolone cheese on panini bread.

wexford location only

The ‘Reubenator’

Traditional reuben done “our way” packed between two grilled swiss cheese sandwiches on marble rye.

wexford location only


Baked Chicken

Baked chicken, roasted portabella mushrooms, Swiss cheese, roasted red peppers, chipotle aioli.

Chicken, Bacon & Artichoke

Roasted chicken, Bacon, and artichokes, swiss cheese with ranch and a white bean spread.

Chicken Mushroom

Baked chicken topped with goat cheese & arugula grilled on focaccia bread and a mushroom truffle spread

wexford location only


House-made meatloaf and mashed potatoes, Apple-wood smoked bacon, Asiago cheese, with our special BBQ sauce and fried onion straws.

Prime Rib

Slow roasted prime rib, caramelized onions, horseradish spread, and alpine lace swiss.

Tomato Basil

Oven roasted tomatoes, housemade basil pesto and fresh mozzarella.

harmar location only


Oven roasted portabellas, spinach, zucchini fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, chipotle aioli on grilled brioche bread.

wexford location only


Pastrami & honey ham with sweet basil dressing, provolone cheese on grilled foccacia with olive spread

wexford location only

Entree Salads

Chicken or Shrimp Ceasar

A larger version of our side salad topped with your choice of chicken or shrimp.

Chicken Bruschetta Salad

A delicious blend of field greens and chopped lettuce with baked chicken, tomatoes, onions, basil and Grilled bruschetta bread tossed with a honey balsamic dressing.

Chopped Chicken Salad

Oven roasted chicken breast, field greens, walnuts, sliced apples & bleu cheese crumbles with herbed Italian dressing.

Crispy Chicken Salad

Chopped lettuce tossed with Parmesan ranch, tomatoes, bacon, cucumbers, and eggs topped with a crispy chicken, green onions, and Parmesan cheese.

wexford location only

Salmon Salad

A blend of field greens and chopped lettuce, tomatoes and feta with honey balsamic dressing.

Tilapia Salad

Herb crusted Tilapia on a bed of field greens with tomatoes, pecans & dried cranberries tossed with a honey balsamic dressing

wexford location only

Side Salads


Romaine lettuce with Asiago cheese crisps and toasted baguette-our twist on a traditional Caesar


Chopped greens with black olives, crumbled feta, red onion, tomatoes and cucumbers in our herbed Italian dressing.

Insalata Toscano

Field greens with grapes, apple-wood smoked bacon, Gorgonzola, tomatoes and honey balsamic dressing.

Insalata Milano

Chopped greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, bacon, fried onions, grated Parmesan, creamy Parmesan dressing



“Assorted flavors” to suit any craving!


How can you resist the classic fudge taste of these brownies !

Rice Crispy Treats

The “Original” treat you remember from your childhood